Vegan Instant Pot Yogurt: Easy, Creamy, and Totally Worth It

Making vegan instant pot yogurt at home is simpler than you think—and far more satisfying than store-bought options. This article explores how to create thick, tangy, dairy-free yogurt in your Instant Pot using just a few ingredients. We’ll cover the benefits, must-have tools, step-by-step instructions, and smart troubleshooting tips so your yogurt comes out perfect every time. Whether you’re new to vegan yogurt or looking to improve your method, this guide has you covered.

A Cozy Journey to Vegan Instant Pot Yogurt

A Cozy Kitchen Memory

Growing up just outside Bath, England, my favorite smells came from the kitchen—roasted parsnips, warm scones, or a bubbling stew. My mum and nan taught me to cook not by recipe, but by feeling: food should make you feel at home. Now, in our Toronto kitchen, my Instant Pot has become an unexpected ally in recreating that comfort, especially with dairy-free recipes like vegan instant pot yogurt.

This yogurt is more than a dairy alternative it’s creamy, spoonable joy. It’s my way of staying connected to those warm memories while embracing a plant-based lifestyle. I can still remember the first time I opened the lid after fermenting what a surprise to see it thick and smooth, just like the full-fat yogurts I grew up with, but entirely made from plants.

Embracing Plant-Based Yogurt Making

Switching to plant-based foods doesn’t mean giving up your favorites. Vegan instant pot yogurt is a prime example. It’s easy to make, customizable in flavor and consistency, and packed with gut-friendly probiotics. Whether you’re using soy, coconut, or almond milk, the Instant Pot’s steady temperature setting takes all the guesswork out.

This method also lets you control what goes in your yogurt no added sugars, gums, or mystery ingredients. And once you’ve got the basics down, you can tweak it to mimic Greek yogurt or even use it as a base for dips and sauces. Making your own vegan yogurt feels empowering, especially when it’s as simple as pressing a button.

Table of Contents

Print

For a variation, try our Instant Pot Coconut Yogurt recipe.

Explore our Instant Pot Greek Yogurt for a different twist.

Why Make Vegan Yogurt in an Instant Pot?

Benefits of Homemade Vegan Yogurt

Making vegan instant pot yogurt at home offers several undeniable benefits. First, it’s cost-effective. Store-bought vegan yogurt can be pricey, especially the thick, tangy varieties. With just plant milk and a probiotic or yogurt starter, you can make a large batch for a fraction of the price.

Secondly, it’s customizable. Want a tangier taste? Ferment it a bit longer. Prefer it thicker? Use soy milk with higher protein or strain it afterward. The Instant Pot provides a consistent, low heat that encourages bacterial fermentation, which is key to a great yogurt. You’re not just saving money you’re taking control of the ingredients and the process.

You also skip unwanted extras. Many store-bought yogurts contain sweeteners, stabilizers, or additives. When you make vegan instant pot yogurt yourself, you use only what you need nothing more, nothing less. Plus, the taste is incredibly fresh. Once you’ve tasted homemade vegan instant pot yogurt, you may not go back to commercial brands.

Instant Pot vs. Traditional Methods

Traditional yogurt-making methods often involve maintaining a stable incubation temperature for hours, which can be tricky without the right tools. That’s where the Instant Pot shines. Its built-in yogurt setting keeps the temperature steady (usually around 110°F/43°C), which is perfect for culturing yogurt.

Without the Instant Pot, you might rely on oven lights, heating pads, or bulky yogurt makers to create that environment. With vegan instant pot yogurt, it’s as easy as pouring, stirring, and pressing a button. That convenience makes it accessible for both seasoned cooks and beginners exploring plant-based living.

This method is particularly reliable for consistent results. Whether you’re crafting your first batch or perfecting your technique, using the Instant Pot to make vegan instant pot yogurt means fewer variables and fewer failed batches. It’s perfect for anyone who wants great dairy-free yogurt with minimal fuss.

Learn more about the benefits in our Instant Pot Yogurt Guide.

Discover tips in our Instant Pot Coconut Yogurt article.

Crafting the Perfect Vegan Yogurt

Essential Ingredients and Tools

Making vegan instant pot yogurt begins with selecting the right plant milk. Not all non-dairy milks perform equally. For best results, use unsweetened, additive-free soy milk—it’s naturally high in protein and produces thick, creamy results without added thickeners. If you prefer coconut milk, choose full-fat canned coconut milk for richness, but be aware the texture may vary slightly.

The second key ingredient is your starter culture. You can use store-bought plain vegan yogurt with live cultures or probiotic capsules. Make sure the label lists active cultures like L. bulgaricus or S. thermophilus. If you’re using a yogurt starter, avoid dairy-based versions they can interfere with fermentation and aren’t suitable for a truly vegan instant pot yogurt.

You’ll also need sterilized jars (glass mason jars work great), a clean spoon, and your Instant Pot with a yogurt function. If you want Greek-style thickness, you’ll need a nut milk bag or cheesecloth to strain the yogurt after it’s cultured.

Step-by-Step Guide to Creamy Yogurt

Once you’ve gathered your ingredients, follow these simple steps to make creamy, tangy vegan instant pot yogurt at home:

1. Sanitize your jars and utensils. This prevents unwanted bacteria from affecting the fermentation.
2. Combine 4 cups of soy milk with 2 tablespoons of your vegan yogurt starter or 1-2 probiotic capsules in a jar. Stir thoroughly.
3. Seal the jars and place them directly into your Instant Pot liner. There’s no need to add water.
4. Set your Instant Pot to the “Yogurt” function and adjust the time to 10–12 hours. Longer fermentation equals tangier yogurt.
5. Once the incubation cycle finishes, move the jars to the refrigerator and let them chill for a minimum of 6 hours to allow the yogurt to set properly.
6. Optional: Strain the yogurt through a cheesecloth to thicken it into a Greek-style texture.

That’s it you’ve just made rich, dairy-free, probiotic-packed vegan instant pot yogurt. From here, you can flavor it with vanilla, sweeten with maple syrup, or stir in fresh fruit.

Vegan instant pot yogurt is also excellent in savory dishes. Use it in place of sour cream for tacos, as a creamy base in curries, or even to make tangy salad dressings. Its versatility is just one more reason to add this staple to your kitchen.

For a sweet treat, check out our Instant Pot Rhubarb Cake.

Pair your yogurt with our Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies.

Troubleshooting and Tips

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Even with a reliable process, making vegan instant pot yogurt can sometimes be tricky. If your yogurt turns out runny or sour in a strange way, don’t worry these issues are often easy to fix.

1. Yogurt didn’t set: This usually means your starter culture wasn’t active. Always check that your probiotic capsules or starter yogurt include live and active cultures. Also, avoid using dairy-based yogurt it won’t work properly in vegan instant pot yogurt and can disrupt fermentation.

2. Yogurt is too thin: Low-protein plant milks like almond or oat can result in watery yogurt. To fix this, either use a thickener like agar agar or switch to soy milk, which yields thicker results naturally. Straining your yogurt after chilling also helps achieve a creamier, Greek-style consistency.

3. Yogurt tastes off: Contamination or expired cultures could be to blame. Make sure all your jars, spoons, and surfaces are sterilized before starting. If in doubt, start fresh with a new batch of probiotic capsules or vegan yogurt.

These small adjustments can dramatically improve your results, helping you enjoy reliable, delicious batches of vegan instant pot yogurt every time.

Enhancing Flavor and Texture

Once you’ve mastered the basics, it’s fun to get creative with your vegan instant pot yogurt. You can flavor it naturally or adjust the texture based on how you plan to use it.

For sweet versions, stir in vanilla extract, cinnamon, or a spoonful of maple syrup after chilling. For a fruit blend, fold in pureed berries or peach compote. Always add flavorings after fermentation adding them too soon can interfere with the cultures.

To get ultra-thick vegan yogurt, strain it for a few hours through a nut milk bag. This is perfect for parfaits or tzatziki. If you’re prepping it for smoothies or baking, leave it unstrained for a more pourable consistency.

With a little practice, you’ll develop your signature style of vegan instant pot yogurt. Once it becomes a kitchen habit, you may find yourself experimenting with different plant milks, probiotic blends, or even layering it into desserts and sauces.

Serve your yogurt alongside our Peruvian Chicken & Rice with Green Sauce.

Add it to your next 7 Layer Dip for a creamy twist.

Conclusion

Vegan instant pot yogurt is one of those simple kitchen wins that quickly becomes a staple. With just a few ingredients and your Instant Pot, you can create creamy, tangy, and customizable dairy-free yogurt at home. It’s affordable, healthier, and endlessly versatile perfect for breakfast bowls, sauces, and even baking.

If you’ve been hesitant to try making your own, this is your sign. The method is straightforward, and the rewards are delicious. Once you taste your first homemade batch, you’ll see why so many plant-based eaters swear by this cozy kitchen essential.

100-Word Story Version

Hi there, I’m Lilly Bennett, the cook behind LillyRecipes.com! Born near Bath, now living in Toronto with my partner Alex and our cat Crumpet, I grew up believing food is love. One of my favorite discoveries? Making vegan instant pot yogurt. It’s easy, satisfying, and way better than store-bought. With just soy milk and a probiotic capsule, the Instant Pot transforms simple ingredients into creamy, tangy goodness overnight. It reminds me of my childhood but fits perfectly into our plant-based life today. Whether for breakfast, baking, or spooned over fruit it’s become a must-have in our fridge.

For more recipes follow me in pinterest

FAQs About Vegan Instant Pot Yogurt